How to Select a Google Ads Agency When Every Audit Looks the Same

If you’ve looked at three or four agency audits in the last few weeks, I’m betting your head is spinning. Every proposal is full of technical details and "impressive" projections, but at a certain point, they all start to sound the same.

I’ve always thought that choosing a PPC partner is less about hiring a "proposal" and more like hiring a new employee. You aren’t just buying a slide deck; you’re hiring a team you’ll hopefully be working with for years.

Here is how I suggest cutting through the noise to find the right fit.

‍

1. Hire the Team, Not the Proposal

My broader suggestion is to hire someone who doesn't just bring an impressive technical audit, but someone you believe can manage the technical stability of your account for years to come. Crucially, you need to philosophically resonate with them.

I often tell brand operators that they are hiring "the team" more than they are hiring "the proposal." Proposals and audits vary wildly based on individual agencies, how they think about optimizations, and their overall PPC philosophy. That has to line up with the way you and your team see things.

The Philosophy Check

For example, we talk a lot about efficiency because we view Google Ads primarily as a tool for capturing existing demand that you’ve already created through other channels (your brand positioning, your offer, your margins, etc.). It is vital that we agree on this. If we don’t, it leads to constant conflict regarding goals and objectives.

I personally think this is the right take because it aligns with the reality of what Google actually does. For some brands, that belief system doesn't resonate at all, and we wouldn't be a good fit for them—unless their expectations of what the Search and Shopping channels can actually accomplish changed.

But here is the rub: if we are correct, then understanding how Google works at a deep level allows us to manage it with extreme efficiency. That sets you up to invest your resources into more successful growth efforts elsewhere. You don’t get that option if you hire someone who keeps pushing you to treat Google as your primary growth driver when it isn’t.

‍

2. The "New Employee" Factor

Hiring an agency is similar to hiring a new employee. The mistake I see many operators make is picking the vendor with the "most impressive proposal" in terms of the promises it makes. This is risky because projections shift constantly.

Worse, sometimes the team proposing the strategy isn't the team actually managing it. That’s not always a dealbreaker, but it’s a massive problem when the proposing team is advanced and the executing team is not.

Stability and Longevity

In our team, our account managers are knowledgeable, they are experienced, and—most importantly—they stick around. I can’t guarantee anything forever, but based on our history, it’s likely that the experts you start with (like Austin or Diana) will be the same ones working on your account for years.

That longevity strengthens your brand just like a good employee does. We’ve had plenty of instances where a new point of contact at a client's company actually has to ask us questions about their own business because we’ve come to know their subtleties so well.

The Great PPCer Rubric

In my biased opinion, a great Google Ads manager is someone who understands these three things and marries them together in the account:

1. The subtleties of the brand they’re advertising.
2. The subtleties of Google Ads.
3. The setup and ongoing optimization that connects the two.

Our team’s deep knowledge and years of experience isn't just a marketing point—it is the "subtlety" of expertise that newer marketers often don't grasp yet. We have basically lived and breathed this for a decade plus. (Even Austin, the "newb" on our team, has about 8 or 9 years of experience!)

It’s hard to explain without working with someone for years, but we’re the team that learns your business, understands the complexities of Google, and implements that effectively as the platform changes.

I can’t guarantee specific KPIs or guess what the market will do in six months, but I can guarantee that with ZATO, you get a knowledgeable, accessible, and stable team. We’ll get things as efficient as possible and care about the account just as much in two years as we do tomorrow.

I hope that helps as you continue to ponder your choice!

‍